Thanksgiving 2025 Pie Order Form —Pittsburgh Pie Guy

Thanksgiving 2025 Pie Order Form —Pittsburgh Pie Guy
Order your Thanksgiving pies from the Pittsburgh Pie Guy here!

***Please note: all pies are available for pickup only, on Wednesday, November 26th, between 10am and 2pm at our kitchen in East Liberty, at the Pittsburgh Theological Seminary, 616 N Highland Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15206.***
- All sweet pies are 10" (large), serve 8-12 people, and are sold fresh
- All quiche are 10" (large), serve 6-8 people, and are sold fresh
- 10" (large) chicken pot pies serve 8 people and are sold fresh
Orders are due by Thursday, November 20th at 10:00pm!

After your order is placed, you will receive a confirmation email with directions for pickup.

If you have any questions about ordering or our products, please email us at pghpieguy@gmail.com or call 412-206-5192.

Note: savory handpies and personal pot pies will be available for purchase when you pick up your preordered pies on Nov. 26th. Savory handpies and personal pot pies are not available for preorder. Inquire about flavors available when you pick up your Thanksgiving pies.

To select a product, please click the tick box in the upper left corner of the product picture and select your quantity from the drop down menu below the product price.

Select your pies*

Sweet Pies

Apple Cranberry Pie (Large 10") Product Image

Apple Cranberry Pie (Large 10")Our housemade flaky butter crust filled with local baking apple varieties & fresh cranberries, and topped with our oat streusel. A holiday favorite! Serves 8–12.

$32.00 Quantity
Item subtotal:$0.00

Pumpkin Pie (Large 10") Product Image

Pumpkin Pie (Large 10")Our housemade flaky butter crust filled with our pumpkin filling made with butternut squash from Who Cooks For You Farm—no cans involved! Serves 8–12.

$32.00 Quantity
Item subtotal:$0.00

Sweet Potato Pie (Large 10") Product Image

Sweet Potato Pie (Large 10")Our housemade flaky butter crust filled with our luscious sweet potato filling made with sweet potatoes from Who Cooks For You Farm. Serves 8–12.

$32.00 Quantity
Item subtotal:$0.00

Apple Pie (Large 10") Product Image

Apple Pie (Large 10")Our housemade flaky butter crust filled with a mix of local baking apple varieties. Serves 8–12.

$32.00 Quantity
Item subtotal:$0.00

Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie Product Image

Chocolate Bourbon Pecan PieOur chocolate butter flaky pie dough filled with our decadent bourbon pecan filling and topped with a chocolate bourbon sauce drizzled on top. Ever-popular! Serves 8-12.

$32.00 Quantity
Item subtotal:$0.00

Pecan Pie (Large 10")Our housemade flaky butter crust filled with our bourbon pecan filling. Serves 8-12

$32.00 Quantity
Item subtotal:$0.00

Quiche

Smoked Salmon & Gouda Quiche (Large 10")Our housemade flaky butter crust filled with our classic quiche custard, cold-smoked salmon, Gouda cheese, and fresh dill. Serves 6-8.

$32.00 Quantity
Item subtotal:$0.00

Broccoli Cheddar Quiche (Large 10")Our housemade flaky butter crust filled with our classic quiche custard, roasted broccoli, and Welsh white cheddar cheese. Serves 6–8.

$30.00 Quantity
Item subtotal:$0.00

Savory Pies

Chicken Pot Pie (Large 10")Perhaps our most popular pie! Fresh chicken thighs, onion, celery, carrots, gravy made with our homemade chicken stock, salt and pepper—that's it! Sure to elicit powerful nostalgia and extreme satisfaction. Serves 8–10

$50.00 Quantity

Total

$0.00

Credit Card

Name*

First NameLast Name
Email*
example@example.com
Phone Number*
Please enter a valid phone number.
Should be Empty: